4 weeks ago
The New York Appeals Court Thursday overturned movie shaper Harvey Weinstein's 2020 rape condemnation and ordered a caller proceedings successful a 4-3 decision. The ruling said nan proceedings judge improperly allowed grounds and grounds that was irrelevant and prejudicial to Weinstein. He remains imprisoned connected a a abstracted rape condemnation successful California. File photograph by John Angelillo/UPI | License Photo
April 25 (UPI) -- The New York Court of Appeals Thursday overturned movie shaper Harvey Weinstein's 2020 rape condemnation and ordered a caller trial.
The appeals tribunal said successful a 4-3 ruling that nan proceedings judge successful Weinstein's New York rape lawsuit improperly allowed grounds and grounds against Weinstein that was "irrelevant" and "prejudicial" to nan criminal charges he faced.
"The proceedings court's rulings ran afoul of these time-honored rules of evidence. Accordingly, nan bid of nan Appellate Division should beryllium reversed, and a caller proceedings ordered," nan appeals tribunal said successful its ruling.
Weinstein was sentenced to 23 years for first-degree rape, a first-degree criminal intersexual enactment and a third-degree rape.
"We are happily surprised and we are studying nan ruling," Weinstein spokesperson Juda Engelmayer told ABC News of nan determination to overturn nan conviction.
The appeals tribunal said Judge James Burke made an "error" successful admitting grounds from women pinch allegations against Weinstein that did not pertain to nan lawsuit which was past "compounded" erstwhile he allowed Weinstein to beryllium cross-examined astir those allegations and different misconduct that portrayed him "in a highly prejudicial right."
The New York Appeals Court ruling said that "under our strategy of justice, nan accused has a correct to beryllium held to relationship only for nan crime charged and, thus, allegations of anterior bad acts whitethorn not beryllium admitted against them for nan sole intent of establishing their propensity for criminality."
"We reaffirm that nary personification accused of illegality whitethorn beryllium judged connected impervious of uncharged crimes that service only to found nan accused's propensity for criminal behavior," nan appeals tribunal mostly wrote successful nan ruling. "At trial, a suspect stands to relationship for nan crimes arsenic charged. Proof of anterior crimes and uncharged bad acts are nan uncommon objection to this basal norm of criminal law."
In a dissent, New York Appeals Court Judge Madeline Singas wrote nan determination represented a "disturbing inclination of overturning juries' blameworthy verdicts successful cases involving intersexual violence."
"This conclusion deprives juries of nan discourse basal to do their work, forecloses nan prosecution from utilizing an basal instrumentality to beryllium intent, ignores nan nuances of really intersexual unit is perpetrated and perceived, and demonstrates nan majority's utter deficiency of knowing of nan dynamics of intersexual assault. Because New York's women merit better, I dissent," Singas said.
Attorney Douglas H. Wigdor, who represented 8 Weinstein accusers, besides condemned nan decision.
"Today's determination is simply a major measurement back successful holding those accountable for acts of intersexual violence," Widgor said.
Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg said successful a connection that his agency would retry nan lawsuit if nan victims are consenting to travel guardant to attest again.
"We will do everything successful our powerfulness to retry this case, and stay patient successful our committedness to survivors of intersexual assault," Bragg said.
Weinstein will stay imprisoned successful California, wherever he was convicted connected abstracted rape charges. The California convictions were 1 count of rape and 2 counts of intersexual assault.
He was sentenced successful Feb. 2023 to 16 years successful situation for nan California charges.
