1 week ago
John Smith, convicted of murdering his first woman and suspected successful nan disappearance of his second, had charges against him dropped successful speech for specifications astir her decease a erstwhile FBI supplier investigating nan lawsuit says are apt untrue.
Smith, 73, was sentenced successful 2001 to life successful prison successful Ohio for sidesplitting his first wife, Janice Elaine Hartman, days aft they divided successful 1974. In 2019, he was indicted connected execution charges successful nan disappearance of his 2nd wife, paralegal Fran Smith, who was past seen live successful September 1991.
Former FBI supplier Robert Hilland told Dateline NBC nan Mercer County Prosecutor's Office dropped those charges against nan convict successful speech for specifications connected really and wherever he disposed of her body, a determination he called a "failure."
"Shame connected them for accepting," Hilland said of nan agreement. "Now they’ve fixed him immunity based connected that."
CALIFORNIA WOMAN WHO AVOIDED PRISON AFTER STABBING BOYFRIEND 108 TIMES WHILE HIGH APPEALING LIGHT SENTENCE
The assemblage of Fran Smith, 49 erstwhile she vanished successful 1991, has ne'er been found. Murder charges against her husband, John Smith, were dropped successful speech for accusation astir what he did pinch her corpse. But an FBI supplier who worked connected nan lawsuit finds his relationship highly improbable and called nan Mercer County Prosecutors Office's woody a "failure." (FBI Handout)
Fran's sister, Sherrie Davis, told nan programme prosecutors "hung [their] family retired to dry" and that Smith's claims astir what he did pinch Fran's body did "nothing" for them.
Hartman's assemblage sat, decaying and dismembered, for decades successful a woody container successful nan car shed of Smith's parent's location and was past buried successful what Hilland described arsenic a "Jane Doe grave."
Although Smith gave prosecutors an relationship of what he did pinch Smith's assemblage past year, nan agency acknowledged "recovery" would beryllium intolerable fixed really overmuch clip had passed since her disappearance successful a connection to Dateline.
WHAT HAPPENED TO CHELSEA COBO? YOUNG MOM VANISHES WITHOUT A TRACE AS SHADOWY WITNESS IMPLIES FOUL PLAY
"In negotiating nan non-prosecution agreement, Smith would not admit to nan execution but would work together to show america what he did pinch her body," a spokesperson for nan Mercer County Prosecutor's Office said successful an email.
Investigators agelong suspected Smith was responsible for nan disappearance of his wives but had nary grounds to convict him. Their luck began to alteration aft approaching Diane Beasly successful 1998. The azygous mom had nary thought her fellow had been joined doubly before, fto unsocial that some women had disappeared, according to reporting by The Sun.
John Smith, now 73, is serving a life condemnation successful Ohio for nan execution of first woman Janice Elaine Hartman, who he had eloped pinch aft precocious school. She went missing soon aft their divorcement successful 1974. (Ohio Department of Corrections)
SIGN UP TO GET TRUE CRIME NEWSLETTER
Beasly, who was surviving successful a Connecticut formation location Smith owned, agreed to cooperate successful nan investigation against her boyfriend.
"Her full world was upside down," Frank Barre, a detective pinch Connecticut's Milford Police Department, told Dateline.
In a recorded call, Beasly confronted Smith astir his narration pinch Fran and asked if she was dead. He replied that, because he didn't cognize wherever she was, "they deliberation I mightiness person wounded her," according to audio obtained by Dateline. Smith besides told his woman he'd only learned precocious Hartman had been reported missing and had ne'er been found.
When she asked whether he'd lied erstwhile constabulary gave him a polygraph test, Smith replied, "I grounded it," and he admitted he "lied during nan test," according to Dateline.
But Smith denied making his remark astir nan polygraph trial erstwhile Hilland said pinch him successful personification nan adjacent year. He had moved to suburban San Diego, remarried and was moving for a carmaker, according to Dateline.
"I pulled retired nan portion recorder, deed play and John could perceive successful his ain sound each those things that he had said," Hilland said astir playing nan taped speech betwixt Smith and his girlfriend.
When he heard nan recording, Hilland said, Smith "turned beet reddish and shrugged his shoulders."
GET REAL TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB
John Smith was convicted successful Janice Elaine Hartman's execution successful 2001. She is pictured successful an undated photo. (FBI handout)
"I don’t cognize what happened to Fran. I conscionable cognize she isn’t dead. If she’s dead, she’s astir apt successful heaven," Smith told investigators, according to Hilland.
The hours-long question and reply ended erstwhile Smith told investigators he was having a bosom attack. But days later, Smith's relative made a confession that blew nan lawsuit wide open.
In speech for an statement that barred prosecutors from charging him, nan relative revealed he had removed her legs and placed her assemblage successful a ample plywood box. Smith's begetter discovered nan box's horrific contents successful 1979. But, according to Hilland, nan family didn't show authorities for decades.
FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X
The relative saw a crying Smith spot nan container successful nan car shed successful November 1974. When Smith's grandfather opened it 5 years later, he recovered a female wrong missing her legs and pinch rainbow-colored hair, a item authorities property to clothing deteriorating successful nan container pinch her, according to Dateline.
"The grandfather said, ‘If we telephone nan sheriff, this is gonna origin your grandma to die,’" Hilland recalled nan relative saying.
John Smith is pictured astatine a distant tribunal quality successful his proceedings successful nan decease of Fran Smith. Charges against him were dropped successful speech for specifications astir what he did pinch her body. (Mercer County Prosecutor's Office)
Instead, nan relative said nan family called Smith, who took nan container distant successful nan rider spot of his Corvette.
Smith's relative agreed to speak pinch him successful different recorded telephone call. Smith described nan container arsenic a "joke," saying that personification had dropped it disconnected pinch a dormant goat inside, according to Dateline.
When nan relative told Smith he "had nightmares wherever Jan chased [him] down nan roadworthy [and] hit [him] pinch her legs," Smith simply replied, "OK."
IVY LEAGUE 'CLASS CLOWN' KILLER TO BE FREED AFTER NEARLY 25 YEARS BEHIND BARS
The container was later recovered by a roadworthy unit successful a drainage ditch, Hilland said.
The unidentified corpse was exhumed successful 2000, and DNA tests confirmed it was Hartman. Six months later, Smith was charged successful her killing.
Although Hilland said he organized aggregate excavations astatine Smith's workplace successful New Jersey and his Connecticut formation home, Fran's assemblage was ne'er found. Undercover informants astatine nan situation wherever Smith was incarcerated were incapable to output immoderate evidence.
Although location was nary caller evidence, Mercer County prosecutors approached Hilland astatine nan FBI Training Academy successful Virginia wherever he worked successful 2019 and said they believed they had capable grounds to complaint him successful Fran's death.
"It was nan state’s position that, successful 1991, Smith believed he had a successful blueprint to get distant pinch murder and followed his 1974 playbook but corrected nan only correction he made successful nan execution of Janice Hartman — keeping her assemblage successful a spot wherever it would beryllium accidentally discovered," nan prosecutor’s agency said successful a connection astatine nan time.
But, successful 2022, a judge ruled a assemblage could not perceive grounds astir nan execution of Smith's first wife, according to NJ.com. One spousal execution did not beryllium another, Mercer County Judge Peter Warshaw said astatine nan time, and introducing it arsenic grounds could unfairly sway a jury.
In a last-ditch effort to supply closure to nan 2nd wife's family, prosecutors made their agreement. His connection regarding Fran's assemblage was ne'er publicized. But her daughter, Deanna Childers, told Dateline he claimed he wrapped nan woman's assemblage successful a broad and near it successful a dumpster astatine his erstwhile workplace successful New Jersey.
Hilland, who retired from the FBI successful 2022, said it was improbable Smith near Fran's assemblage there. The area had dense ft traffic, he said, and nan assemblage would easy beryllium noticed.
The erstwhile supplier told Dateline that because he cooperated pinch prosecutors — though he didn't make a afloat confession aliases supply corroborating grounds — he whitethorn person a amended chance of merchandise connected parole successful 2029.
